What should I do if I catch an employee stealing?

The moment you catch an employee stealing hits like a betrayal, whether it’s fingers in the till, inventory vanishing into thin air, or company credit cards funding personal shopping sprees. Your business, built on trust, now faces a crisis demanding immediate action. However, before making decisions that could expose your business to legal complications, consult with an employment solicitor who specialises in workplace theft cases.

Learn how to handle employee theft legally while protecting your business from costly tribunal claims.

Do you need a solicitor?

We will connect you with the right solicitor, near you.

Find a solicitor near me Request a call

Step 1: Initial discovery and documentation

When you catch an employee stealing on camera UK, your first actions are crucial:

• Document the incident precisely: date, time, exactly what was taken, and how you discovered it.
• Secure all evidence immediately: CCTV footage, transaction records, photographs, and witness statements.
• Maintain strict confidentiality throughout: sharing information with other staff risks defamation claims and compromises your investigation.

This careful initial documentation creates the essential foundation for all subsequent disciplinary or legal actions.

Step 2: Reviewing company policies and procedures

After you catch an employee stealing, immediately review your company’s relevant policies:

• Ensure compliance with employment law requirements for fair investigations and hearings.
• Check employment contracts and staff handbooks for specific theft clauses and disciplinary procedures.
• Understand your established disciplinary process; informal warnings, formal meetings, and grounds for dismissal.

This review prevents procedural mistakes that could undermine your case and helps determine whether the theft constitutes gross misconduct warranting dismissal.

Step 3: Building your case

After you catch an employee stealing, systematically gather compelling evidence:

• Secure physical evidence including missing inventory records, altered documents, or recovered stolen items.
• Obtain written statements from witnesses using consistent questioning, documenting their direct observations rather than assumptions.
• Collect financial records showing discrepancies, CCTV footage capturing the act, and digital evidence like suspicious system access logs or emails.

This comprehensive evidentiary documentation creates a robust case that can withstand scrutiny in disciplinary proceedings or employment tribunals.

Step 4: Conducting a proper investigation

When you catch an employee stealing, assemble a small, discrete investigation team, typically a manager, HR representative, and possibly security personnel. Following that, adopt strict interview protocols:

• Conduct discussions in private, allow employee representation, ask open questions, and avoid leading or accusatory language.
• Document every investigative step meticulously, including meeting minutes, interview recordings (with consent), and investigation findings.

This procedural fairness demonstrates you’ve conducted a reasonable investigation that meets ACAS guidelines and protects your business from unfair dismissal claims.

Step 5: The confrontation meeting

After you catch an employee stealing and complete your investigation, prepare for a formal disciplinary meeting:

• Send a written invitation specifying the allegations, possible consequences including dismissal, and the employee’s right to representation.
• During the meeting, remain composed and objective while presenting your evidence chronologically.
• Allow the employee uninterrupted time to respond to each allegation.
• Document their explanations, admissions, or denials precisely in meeting minutes.

This fair hearing demonstrates procedural justice regardless of whether you ultimately terminate their employment.

Step 6: Determining appropriate action

Following the disciplinary meeting with an employee caught stealing, select a proportionate response matching the offense’s gravity:

• For minimal value theft with genuine remorse, issue formal written warnings with clear improvement expectations.
• Implement temporary suspension with pay during deliberation for more serious cases.
• Reserve dismissal for clear gross misconduct supported by compelling evidence.
• Involve police when theft exceeds £500, involves forgery/fraud, or requires criminal record documentation for future employers.

Your chosen sanction must reflect workplace disciplinary standards that would be considered reasonable by an employment tribunal.

Step 7: Implementing disciplinary measures

Implement your decision after you catch an employee stealing by following a structured process:

• Deliver the outcome in a private meeting first, then provide written confirmation detailing the decision, supporting evidence, and reasoning.
• Include specific information about any sanctions imposed, consequences of further misconduct, and the employee’s right to appeal.
• Document every communication thoroughly, collecting signatures where appropriate.
• Maintain strict confidentiality when informing other staff members of outcomes, sharing only essential operational information.

This disciplinary documentation creates an audit trail protecting your business from potential unfair dismissal claims.

Step 8: Recovering stolen assets

Once you’ve addressed the disciplinary aspects after you catch an employee stealing, focus on financial recovery:

Request voluntary repayment with a formal agreement specifying amounts and payment schedule.

• File comprehensive insurance claims with documented evidence of loss and disciplinary outcomes.
• For substantial theft, consider small claims court (for amounts under £10,000) or county court proceedings, which provide legally enforceable judgments.
• Explore statutory demand letters for undisputed debts before legal action.

These civil recovery methods can help recoup losses without expensive litigation, though success depends on the employee’s financial situation.

Step 9: Preventing future incidents

After you catch an employee stealing, implement systemic safeguards to prevent recurrence:

• Install enhanced surveillance in vulnerable areas, strengthen cash handling protocols with dual-verification systems, and conduct regular unannounced audits.
• Address potential cultural contributors by evaluating compensation fairness, recognition programs, and management transparency.
• Develop comprehensive theft prevention training for all staff covering company policies, reporting procedures, and consequences of dishonesty.

These preventative measures demonstrate to insurers, employees, and stakeholders that you’ve converted an unfortunate incident into meaningful security improvements.

FAQs

• What are employee rights when accused of theft in the UK? Employees have the right to know allegations, see evidence, bring a representative to meetings, respond to accusations, and appeal decisions. They’re entitled to a fair investigation following ACAS guidelines regardless of evidence strength. Employers must maintain confidentiality throughout the process.
• How do I report employee theft to the police in the UK? Call 101 or visit your local police station with all evidence (CCTV, statements, financial records). You’ll receive a crime reference number for insurance claims. There’s no legal obligation to report, but it creates an official record and may protect future employers.
• What are the theft from employer sentencing guidelines in the UK? Sentences depend on value and breach of trust. Thefts under £500 typically result in community orders or fines. £500-£10,000 may bring community orders or 1-3 year sentences for higher culpability cases. Thefts exceeding £10,000 can attract 2-7 year prison terms.

Handling cases where you catch an employee stealing requires careful balancing of disciplinary action and legal compliance. By following proper procedures, documenting evidence thoroughly, and seeking professional guidance when needed, you can address theft effectively while protecting your business from unfair dismissal claims and maintaining workplace trust.

Protect your business!

When you catch an employee stealing, time is critical. Qredible’s network of specialist employment solicitors provides expert guidance through every step of this challenging process.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• When you catch an employee stealing, document all evidence thoroughly and maintain strict confidentiality to create a legally defensible foundation for your actions.
• Follow proper disciplinary procedures including formal meetings, allowing employee representation, and providing written documentation of all decisions to ensure procedural fairness.
• Consider appropriate sanctions based on theft severity, from written warnings to dismissal, ensuring your response is proportionate and reasonable.
• Implement preventative measures including enhanced security protocols, cultural improvements, and comprehensive training to prevent future incidents.
• Consult with employment solicitors for high-value thefts or potential dismissals to protect your business from costly unfair dismissal claims.